Moroccan is the one I hear IRL. I can't imagine any dialect of Arabic being pretty... unless they give up all their /x/-like sounds and glottal stops and whatever, which I don't know if is the case for Egyptian since I don't really know anything about Arabic.Yng wrote:But WHAT Arabic? dialects vary so much it's pretty much impossible to pass judgement on all of them. I think most Maghreb dialects are ugly as sin and likewise Iraqi, but Levantine and Egyptian are quite pretty (although Levantine sounds a bit whiny).
Nice sounding natlangs
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
So have I changed your opinion?Skomakar'n wrote:That was nice.Shrdlu wrote:Sko,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9-0ScD4Yec
If I stop posting out of the blue it probably is because my computer and the board won't cooperate and let me log in.!
- Ser
- Smeric
- Posts: 1542
- Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2008 1:55 am
- Location: Vancouver, British Columbia / Colombie Britannique, Canada
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Erm, Moroccan doesn't even have glottal stops... And uvular/pharyngeal/epiglottal sounds are not necessarily markers of ugliness: apparently [ʁ ~ ʀ̥] is statistically the most common sound in French and people still like it. :/Eandil wrote:Moroccan is the one I hear IRL. I can't imagine any dialect of Arabic being pretty... unless they give up all their /x/-like sounds and glottal stops and whatever, which I don't know if is the case for Egyptian since I don't really know anything about Arabic.Yng wrote:But WHAT Arabic? dialects vary so much it's pretty much impossible to pass judgement on all of them. I think most Maghreb dialects are ugly as sin and likewise Iraqi, but Levantine and Egyptian are quite pretty (although Levantine sounds a bit whiny).
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
So? All I said holds true. No, I don't hear the glottal stops in Moroccan; but yes, I know Arabic as a whole has them and it contributes to the ugliness, so I added it anyway. And that factoid about ʁ will not change my (or anybody's I guess) opinion that Arabic is ugly; firstly because it's stupid to argue people's impressions (not like they're reasoned, they're... likings) and secondly because the argument is irrelevant, as much as you like Arabic, the phonology as a whole having uvulars, pharyngeals and epiglottals makes it sound ugly to many's ears - and that people like French doesn't mean they like that sound about French [plus people who hate French often do because of the sound, and the number of people who dislike French is not unimportant, for example my sister, and me myself sometimes].Sinjana wrote:Erm, Moroccan doesn't even have glottal stops... And uvular/pharyngeal/epiglottal sounds are not necessarily markers of ugliness: apparently [ʁ ~ ʀ̥] is statistically the most common sound in French and people still like it. :/
Overall, my most reasoned argument for disliking Arabic is that from the people I've heard it, it sounds as if they were about to puke, no matter what they were saying.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Personally, I don't find French all that attractive. I like Portuguese (which seems very much in the speaker's nose) and I absolutely adore Arabic (which seems to be in the speakers throat), but French, being both nasally and uvular, is just a bad combination of the two. IMHO.Eandil wrote:[plus people who hate French often do because of the sound, and the number of people who dislike French is not unimportant, for example my sister, and me myself sometimes].
.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
The Portuguese variety I speak is also rich in ʁ, which combined with the nasality (I concur) makes me unable to say "oh this is so beautiful", but I don't find it horrible because I speak it. I guess that if I spoke Arabic my opinion would change, they say recitations of the Qur'an are charming, for instance.Vuvgangujunga wrote:Personally, I don't find French all that attractive. I like Portuguese (which seems very much in the speaker's nose) and I absolutely adore Arabic (which seems to be in the speakers throat), but French, being both nasally and uvular, is just a bad combination of the two. IMHO.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
I was talking about a variety of BRAZILIAN Portuguese (which I know to actual Portuguese people sounds like an insane moon man language, but still), which had /X/. I don't know why, but I find /X/ to be less throaty than /ʁ/. I guess it's because I don't hear it as well.Eandil wrote: The Portuguese variety I speak is also rich in ʁ, which combined with the nasality (I concur) makes me unable to say "oh this is so beautiful", but I don't find it horrible because I speak it. I guess that if I spoke Arabic my opinion would change, they say recitations of the Qur'an are charming, for instance.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
If Brazilian didn't have palatalization, I'd like it much more than I do now.Vuvgangujunga wrote:I was talking about a variety of BRAZILIAN Portuguese (which I know to actual Portuguese people sounds like an insane moon man language, but still), which had /X/. I don't know why, but I find /X/ to be less throaty than /ʁ/. I guess it's because I don't hear it as well.
A Brazilian-American friend of mine told me that Portugal Portuguese sounded to her like Chinese xD.
Most of the time I hear Brazilian it seems like just [h].
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Portuguese Portuguese sounds like Russian.
Danish sounds like Chinese.
Trufax.
Danish sounds like Chinese.
Trufax.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
tbh I've never heard Danish.Jipí wrote:Portuguese Portuguese sounds like Russian.
Danish sounds like Chinese.
Trufax.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
-
Portugeuse
(Standard) Italian. Haven't heard other Italian dialects/languages, so I can't say about the others.
Catalan
Loud Mandarin on buses or the train, like any other language spoken loudly by inconsiderate people. But loud Mandarin annoys me more for some reason.
+
Maori
Any Australian language I've ever heard.
Japanese
Korean
Portugeuse
(Standard) Italian. Haven't heard other Italian dialects/languages, so I can't say about the others.
Catalan
Loud Mandarin on buses or the train, like any other language spoken loudly by inconsiderate people. But loud Mandarin annoys me more for some reason.
+
Maori
Any Australian language I've ever heard.
Japanese
Korean
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Good
Italian, some of the people I know who speak it make it sound really too whiney, but it's good overall, and it's easy
Swedish and Norwegian, I like what I hear and it's easy to get the hang of,like German without the annoying sound
Hausa, this language sounds very sweet, even breathy. I like a lot of African languages even if I think the vowel quality is too harsh quite frequently.
Japanese, very neat sound, i like most words and sentences but the glottal stops at the end and beginning make it all too clipped-sounding. And I like Korean, at least when it's spoken by Lady Rainicorn.
The Slavic languages are pretty cool. I don't like Russian but I like Polish and Bosnian.
I like Irish but dislike Scottish. Scots sounds kind of flat intonation-wise.
Estonian
Bad
Spanish, this language sounds really harsh and clipped, and Mexican Spanish is too slow. Insipid.
Portuguese,sounds good but I can't tell what you're saying. A lot of stuff just seems too rounded off like final L.
French, even worse than Portugese but I can amazingly enough understand everything. Sound kind of like parrots.
Native American languages, they don't sound like they have much for intonation patterns but the words are kind of nice like with Japanese.
German mostly because the uvulars but it can be kind of funny when spoken by Klaus on American Dad.
Mandarin, I've never heard spoken in a way I like, super whiney and painful. Also too many sibilants and kind of clipped.
Some languages just sound louder than others andi like the quiet, private ones, ie Japanese, polish and Italian and Hausa.
Italian, some of the people I know who speak it make it sound really too whiney, but it's good overall, and it's easy
Swedish and Norwegian, I like what I hear and it's easy to get the hang of,like German without the annoying sound
Hausa, this language sounds very sweet, even breathy. I like a lot of African languages even if I think the vowel quality is too harsh quite frequently.
Japanese, very neat sound, i like most words and sentences but the glottal stops at the end and beginning make it all too clipped-sounding. And I like Korean, at least when it's spoken by Lady Rainicorn.
The Slavic languages are pretty cool. I don't like Russian but I like Polish and Bosnian.
I like Irish but dislike Scottish. Scots sounds kind of flat intonation-wise.
Estonian
Bad
Spanish, this language sounds really harsh and clipped, and Mexican Spanish is too slow. Insipid.
Portuguese,sounds good but I can't tell what you're saying. A lot of stuff just seems too rounded off like final L.
French, even worse than Portugese but I can amazingly enough understand everything. Sound kind of like parrots.
Native American languages, they don't sound like they have much for intonation patterns but the words are kind of nice like with Japanese.
German mostly because the uvulars but it can be kind of funny when spoken by Klaus on American Dad.
Mandarin, I've never heard spoken in a way I like, super whiney and painful. Also too many sibilants and kind of clipped.
Some languages just sound louder than others andi like the quiet, private ones, ie Japanese, polish and Italian and Hausa.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Seems like a pretty huge generalization.meltman wrote:Native American languages, they don't sound like they have much for intonation patterns but the words are kind of nice like with Japanese.
Good:
Japanese
Lakota
Inuktitut
Bad:
English w/ Boston accent (I don't know what bothers me so much about it. I like the GA accent, don't mind most of the other American accents, but man Boston's really gets to me.)
Thai
Italian
- Ser
- Smeric
- Posts: 1542
- Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2008 1:55 am
- Location: Vancouver, British Columbia / Colombie Britannique, Canada
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Where are you from? You don't seem to be versed in US stereotypes, which are pretty much the opposite of these two (Mexican Spanish is thought to be fast over there, and Italian loud).meltman wrote:Spanish, this language sounds really harsh and clipped, and Mexican Spanish is too slow. Insipid.
Some languages just sound louder than others andi like the quiet, private ones, ie [...] Italian[...].
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Btw, Sinjana, I was wondering, what are the stereotypes of Peninsular to you El Salvadorans and other hispanoamericans, in case you know? Lisp lisp lisp?Sinjana wrote:Where are you from? You don't seem to be versed in US stereotypes, which are pretty much the opposite of these two (Mexican Spanish is thought to be fast over there, and Italian loud).
- Ser
- Smeric
- Posts: 1542
- Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2008 1:55 am
- Location: Vancouver, British Columbia / Colombie Britannique, Canada
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Lisp, lisp, lisp. Yeah.
And saying ¡coño!, ¡joder!, ¡cojones!, ¡carajo! ¡gilipollas!, ¡capullo! every couple of seconds.
And saying ¡coño!, ¡joder!, ¡cojones!, ¡carajo! ¡gilipollas!, ¡capullo! every couple of seconds.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
So lisp, insults, and loudness (according to Torco), lol.Sinjana wrote:Lisp, lisp, lisp. Yeah.
And saying ¡coño!, ¡joder!, ¡cojones!, ¡carajo! ¡gilipollas!, ¡capullo! every couple of seconds.
The funny part is that it's true xD.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
I don't think Mongolian would qualify as a "nice-sounding" language, but I like it anyway. Of all the languages I am familiar with the sound of, Mongolian seems the most to me like just a bunch of random sounds thrown at each other and pronounced whatever way they happened to fall.
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
What a highly elaborate judgement.meltman wrote:German mostly because the uvulars but it can be kind of funny when spoken by Klaus on American Dad.
Let me guess. You've only heard German on the internet, i.e. in clips from The Downfall, and maybe in some other American WW2 flicks, and as parodied through a cartoon character that likely wasn't even voiced by a native German speaker. You may have had some grandparent who still spoke German to you as a child, but that was awkward and you didn't like that they did. What I want to say is that German's rap in my experience seems to be mostly based on stereotypes of nazis when people on the internet say they don't like it for its "gutturalness", or more elaborately, "its use of uvulars".
- Ser
- Smeric
- Posts: 1542
- Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2008 1:55 am
- Location: Vancouver, British Columbia / Colombie Britannique, Canada
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
I've never actually heard the stereotype of speaking loud in El Salvador, not until I joined the forums and saw Europeans mentioning it altogether actually.Eandil wrote:So lisp, insults, and loudness (according to Torco), lol.Sinjana wrote:Lisp, lisp, lisp. Yeah.
And saying ¡coño!, ¡joder!, ¡cojones!, ¡carajo! ¡gilipollas!, ¡capullo! every couple of seconds.
The funny part is that it's true xD.
Oh, and the demonym is "Salvador(i)an" in English, and salvadoreño in Spanish (no El, though in Spanish, if it's preceded by a de, it is indeed written as de El Salvador).
- communistplot
- Avisaru
- Posts: 494
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:49 am
- Location: La Ciudad de Nueva York
- Contact:
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Oooh, lists, I <3 lists:
Success
Non-Rhotic English Dialects (minus Bostonian, but that's only due to my bias as a NYer)
Spanish, it's a beautiful language especially as spoken by us Puerto Ricans, though I will say (as much as I still enjoy it) Peninsular Spanish speakers, especially ones who've retained /T/ sound kinda pompous.
Portuguese, both European & Brazilian, if I were to serenade a girl, I'd use Portuguese it comes off as very romantic to me.
Sardinian, Romance with retroflexes? Yes, another beautiful sounding language in it's quirkiness.
Arabic, especially beautiful when sung but that's true for me of all Semitic languages.
Hebrew, as said before, sung Hebrew is amazingly beautiful, it's why I enjoy synagogue.
Japanese, my first love, it's always kinda sounded like someone was telling a children's tale whenever they speak it.
Swedish, my current love, it's so sing-songy and delicious, I love Germanic languages in general though.
Fail
Most Rhotic English dialects, except West Country, Scottish & Vermontese, whenever I hear a rhotic dialect, and this ain't necessarily a bad thing, I think of farming and farmers. I find rhotacism to be an ugly feature though.
French, ugh French, it's never won any linguistic wars, it sounds terrible to my ears, I feel like when Latin was passing out features to it's daughters, French, and oïl languages in general, got all the bad ones. And like Peninsular it sounds pompous though with a lack of anything pleasant sounding.
Mongolian, Mongolian, it's Mongolic, I honestly don't know what I don't like about it, it just sounds funny I guess.
Latvian, the lesser sounding Lithuanian.
Success
Non-Rhotic English Dialects (minus Bostonian, but that's only due to my bias as a NYer)
Spanish, it's a beautiful language especially as spoken by us Puerto Ricans, though I will say (as much as I still enjoy it) Peninsular Spanish speakers, especially ones who've retained /T/ sound kinda pompous.
Portuguese, both European & Brazilian, if I were to serenade a girl, I'd use Portuguese it comes off as very romantic to me.
Sardinian, Romance with retroflexes? Yes, another beautiful sounding language in it's quirkiness.
Arabic, especially beautiful when sung but that's true for me of all Semitic languages.
Hebrew, as said before, sung Hebrew is amazingly beautiful, it's why I enjoy synagogue.
Japanese, my first love, it's always kinda sounded like someone was telling a children's tale whenever they speak it.
Swedish, my current love, it's so sing-songy and delicious, I love Germanic languages in general though.
Fail
Most Rhotic English dialects, except West Country, Scottish & Vermontese, whenever I hear a rhotic dialect, and this ain't necessarily a bad thing, I think of farming and farmers. I find rhotacism to be an ugly feature though.
French, ugh French, it's never won any linguistic wars, it sounds terrible to my ears, I feel like when Latin was passing out features to it's daughters, French, and oïl languages in general, got all the bad ones. And like Peninsular it sounds pompous though with a lack of anything pleasant sounding.
Mongolian, Mongolian, it's Mongolic, I honestly don't know what I don't like about it, it just sounds funny I guess.
Latvian, the lesser sounding Lithuanian.
The Artist Formerly Known as Caleone
My Conlangs (WIP):
Pasic - Proto-Northeastern Bay - Asséta - Àpzó
My Conlangs (WIP):
Pasic - Proto-Northeastern Bay - Asséta - Àpzó
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
qué dices [ke 'di.TE]Caleone wrote:Spanish, it's a beautiful language especially as spoken by us Puerto Ricans, though I will say (as much as I still enjoy it) Peninsular Spanish speakers, especially ones who've retained /T/ sound kinda pompous.
(xD pompous? )
- communistplot
- Avisaru
- Posts: 494
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:49 am
- Location: La Ciudad de Nueva York
- Contact:
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Oh gawd, I just had flashbacks of my 10th grade Spanish teacher, who declared all Latin American dialects to not be true Spanish, our school was full of Puerto Ricans & Dominicans and thus we all hated her.Eandil wrote:qué dices [ke 'di.TE]Caleone wrote:Spanish, it's a beautiful language especially as spoken by us Puerto Ricans, though I will say (as much as I still enjoy it) Peninsular Spanish speakers, especially ones who've retained /T/ sound kinda pompous.
(xD pompous? )
The Artist Formerly Known as Caleone
My Conlangs (WIP):
Pasic - Proto-Northeastern Bay - Asséta - Àpzó
My Conlangs (WIP):
Pasic - Proto-Northeastern Bay - Asséta - Àpzó
- communistplot
- Avisaru
- Posts: 494
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:49 am
- Location: La Ciudad de Nueva York
- Contact:
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Oh gawd, I just had flashbacks of my 10th grade Spanish teacher, who declared all Latin American dialects to not be true Spanish, our school was full of Puerto Ricans & Dominicans and thus we all hated her.Eandil wrote:qué dices [ke 'di.TE]Caleone wrote:Spanish, it's a beautiful language especially as spoken by us Puerto Ricans, though I will say (as much as I still enjoy it) Peninsular Spanish speakers, especially ones who've retained /T/ sound kinda pompous.
(xD pompous? )
The Artist Formerly Known as Caleone
My Conlangs (WIP):
Pasic - Proto-Northeastern Bay - Asséta - Àpzó
My Conlangs (WIP):
Pasic - Proto-Northeastern Bay - Asséta - Àpzó
Re: Nice sounding natlangs
Beause it's true!! Stop seseating my true language!!Caleone wrote:Oh gawd, I just had flashbacks of my 10th grade Spanish teacher, who declared all Latin American dialects to not be true Spanish, our school was full of Puerto Ricans & Dominicans and thus we all hated her.
Just kidding. You should've told her that if she wanted to be sooo authentic she'd have to go back to the Golden Age and speak like Cervantes; or even better, back to Cid's time. But I presume she didn't realize Quijote as Quixote xD.
P.S.: On the other hand, linguistically you're all just one big basement in Seville haha.