Short survey on English
-
- Avisaru
- Posts: 704
- Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2010 9:41 am
- Location: NY, USA
Short survey on English
1. That is the reason why we keep that door closed.
2. That is the reason we keep that door closed.
3. That is why we keep that door closed.
Do you find any of these unacceptable? Which do you prefer, if any? Can you explain?
2. That is the reason we keep that door closed.
3. That is why we keep that door closed.
Do you find any of these unacceptable? Which do you prefer, if any? Can you explain?
Re: Short survey on English
Number 3 is acceptable and probably number 2, number 1 I don't like as much. For the first two I keep wanting to use this or some other change of syntax.Bob Johnson wrote:1. That is the reason why we keep that door closed.
2. That is the reason we keep that door closed.
3. That is why we keep that door closed.
Do you find any of these unacceptable? Which do you prefer, if any? Can you explain?
- Lyhoko Leaci
- Avisaru
- Posts: 716
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2006 1:20 pm
- Location: Not Mariya's road network, thankfully.
Re: Short survey on English
#3 sounds the best, but none of them sound really wrong. I have no idea of how to explain this. Maybe just because it's shorter.
Zain pazitovcor, sio? Sio, tovcor.
You can't read that, right? Yes, it says that.
You can't read that, right? Yes, it says that.
Shinali Sishi wrote:"Have I spoken unclearly? I meant electric catfish not electric onions."
Re: Short survey on English
All acceptable, no real differences except for the timing/length of utterance/etc. For me, at least. In casual speech, I'd be more likely to say the third, but I think it's probably just because it's faster. I kind of feel like it should be "the door" instead of "that door", but that's probably context-dependent.
It's (broadly) [faɪ.ˈjuw.lɛ]
#define FEMALE
ConlangDictionary 0.3 3/15/14 (ZBB thread)
Quis vult in terra stare,
Cum possit volitare?
#define FEMALE
ConlangDictionary 0.3 3/15/14 (ZBB thread)
Quis vult in terra stare,
Cum possit volitare?
- linguofreak
- Lebom
- Posts: 123
- Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 10:39 pm
- Location: Somewhere
- Contact:
Re: Short survey on English
Well, all of them sound much more natural with "That's" rather than "that is".Bob Johnson wrote:1. That is the reason why we keep that door closed.
2. That is the reason we keep that door closed.
3. That is why we keep that door closed.
Do you find any of these unacceptable? Which do you prefer, if any? Can you explain?
#1 sounds a bit weird, but the general construction "the reason why we..." doesn't.
I also might say "That's the reason that we keep that door closed."
Re: Short survey on English
prefer 2, none ungrammatical to me, non-native.
Re: Short survey on English
They are all acceptable, with 3 being the best and 1 being the worst of the three. 1 is too redundant and wordy.
- Lyhoko Leaci
- Avisaru
- Posts: 716
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2006 1:20 pm
- Location: Not Mariya's road network, thankfully.
Re: Short survey on English
Seconded on this, though keeping them separate sounds a bit better if you are stressing "that", though that could still be combined as a stressed "that's".linguofreak wrote: Well, all of them sound much more natural with "That's" rather than "that is".
Zain pazitovcor, sio? Sio, tovcor.
You can't read that, right? Yes, it says that.
You can't read that, right? Yes, it says that.
Shinali Sishi wrote:"Have I spoken unclearly? I meant electric catfish not electric onions."
-
- Avisaru
- Posts: 704
- Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2010 9:41 am
- Location: NY, USA
Re: Short survey on English
Note the italics on <that>: it's heavily stressed. Not really the point, though it is interesting. (And again...)Lyhoko Leaci wrote:Seconded on this, though keeping them separate sounds a bit better if you are stressing "that", though that could still be combined as a stressed "that's".linguofreak wrote:Well, all of them sound much more natural with "That's" rather than "that is".
Now that I'm a bit down the page: I heavily prefer simply "why" here, but I hear "the reason why" all the time, and I wonder (at the reason) why people use it when they could say only "the reason" or "why" instead. It sounds pleonastic to me. I know it's not modern; it shows up in everything from Shakespeare on:
I figure there might be some prosodic or intonation effect -- which seems in line with what I'm seeing here so far -- but I'm not sure what exactly that effect might be.As You Like It III.ii wrote:ROSALIND. Love is merely a madness; and, I tell you, deserves as well a dark house and a whip as madmen do: and the reason why they are not so punished and cured is, that the lunacy is so ordinary that the whippers are in love too. Yet I profess curing it by counsel
Re: Short survey on English
I have a vague sense that 1 might be less acceptable than the others, possibly because "why" seems redundant after "the reason". I'd also want to correct 3 to "That's" instead of "That is".Bob Johnson wrote:1. That is the reason why we keep that door closed.
2. That is the reason we keep that door closed.
3. That is why we keep that door closed.
Do you find any of these unacceptable? Which do you prefer, if any? Can you explain?
That said, it took me a minute to figure out what you were asking about, so i'd say they're all fine to me.
Re: Short survey on English
All three sound perfectly natural to me.
http://www.veche.net/
http://www.veche.net/novegradian - Grammar of Novegradian
http://www.veche.net/alashian - Grammar of Alashian
http://www.veche.net/novegradian - Grammar of Novegradian
http://www.veche.net/alashian - Grammar of Alashian
Re: Short survey on English
All are fine. 3 is shortest, so it's probably the best. I suspect I might produce #2 or #3, but not produce #1, although it sounds fine.
It makes me think of this, although the part of speech is different:
It makes me think of this, although the part of speech is different:
Theirs not to reason why,
Theirs but to do and die.
Re: Short survey on English
They're all cool, but 3 is the one I prefer because it gets the same point across with less words.
Re: Short survey on English
All are fine. 2 is a bit formal, or it could be in response to the question "what's the reason we keep that door closed" followed by an action which explains it. 1 I feel would be likely in a list of doors and why they're kept closed.
Re: Short survey on English
They're all fine; prefer 3, then 2, slight disprefernce for 1 due to the redundant (but not ungrammatical) "reason why" of one. My choice seems to be guided by a liking for brevity. Not sure which one I'd actually say in a real situation where that was the appropriate comment.
- vampireshark
- Avisaru
- Posts: 738
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2008 7:02 pm
- Location: Luxembourg
- Contact:
Re: Short survey on English
While they all sound right to me, they have different intonations (it feels), so I'd say them in different cases. Utterance 3 would probably only come after a physical demonstration of the reason, while number 1 would be more likely to appear in casual speech after an explanation (with a variance between that and number 2, preference for the first one).
What do you see in the night?
In search ofvictims subjects to appear on banknotes. Inquire within.
In search of
Re: Short survey on English
They're all perfectly acceptable to me, though the first one could be criticized in formal writing since "the reason why" constitutes a pleonasm (i.e. an unnecessary redundancy), but in speech it would be fine. Conversely, I feel the second one would be more likely used in formal writing than in speech. The third one works all around.
Chances are it's Ryukyuan (Resources).
Re: Short survey on English
Change "that door" to "the door" if there is no context. Saying "that door" implies there was a whole story about a series of doors, each with their own complicated lore informing us why it isn't opened. And as others have stated, "that's" would work better in some contexts, especially for two and three.
Number one sounds like it's deliberately drawn out, like the last sentence of a long story "And that, Children, is the reason why Mister Toad decided to eat his vegetables."
Number two sounds like it's the answer to a question.
Number three is the most natural in conversation, but it's impossible to say for sure without context.
Number one sounds like it's deliberately drawn out, like the last sentence of a long story "And that, Children, is the reason why Mister Toad decided to eat his vegetables."
Number two sounds like it's the answer to a question.
Number three is the most natural in conversation, but it's impossible to say for sure without context.
[quote="Nortaneous"]Is South Africa better off now than it was a few decades ago?[/quote]