Yay thread revival! Yay new contributors! Yay past contributors coming back for more! Welcome welcome!
(I seem to be finding myself somehow more (pre)occupied these days than in the past, but I'm still around, reading everything and working on stuff in my slowpoke way. I keep thinking I should drop by #akana sometime, but I've been putting it off because it seems like when I do, I always spend the whole afternoon there...)
Anyway, some questions and comments:
I believe the region you've labelled "Western Plateau" is where the
Zmůwø Mountains are. Also, the Rathedān proper is still slightly further east than you put it: it should basically comprise the highlands between the Thabīa, Milīr, and Aiwa valleys (thus it doesn't extend west of the Thabīa at all).
I'm also not sure where all those tiny lakes are coming from... they look a little excessive to me. I think a lot of the lakes along rivers on Earth are artificial, created by modern dams. (Maybe what I'm reacting to is more the style of map than the content though-- I find all those little fiddly lines kind of busy-looking.)
Radius Solis wrote:- The big river west of where you put Xshalad should enter the sea further east, not at the head of that gulf. ... The Xshalad empire is centered on the lower reaches of this river, on its floodplain.
Is this river still called the Yima?
cedh audmanh wrote:The Western Steppe region looks a bit too dry now though, with all those rivers being seasonal. I think this region could also benefit from some height relief.
I agree. Actually, it seems like we need a Western Coastal Range to cast a rainshadow over the steppe-- otherwise it should mostly be forest, like western Europe, shouldn't it?
cedh audmanh wrote:Also, I'm not sure which of the world maps you based this on, but it appears you didn't use
the latest one.
I've been using
this map as a base map for my own sketching purposes, but I've noticed it's a little different than the one with tectonics-- I take it the tectonics one is more correct then?
- Some coastlines of islands in the Sumarušuxi region have been modified. Notably, Ik'im is much smaller now.
I've wondered why you did this, actually-- do you remember the reason?
- I've been working on a satellite-style map of Siixtaguna recently ...
Wow. Sounds cool!
thedukeofnuke wrote:Most importantly: a
version of the Lukpanic map with ethnic groups in about -500 YP. Locations are tentative and I'll change them if they don't work, but I've assigned them based on descriptions in the grammars. Some, like the Wañelinlawag Empire, are reasonably firm - it looks like descendants of Alces' Naəgbum dialect will end up being the most important languages of the late 1st millennium BP due to interaction with the said Empire, which reaches its height at the time of the map.
My first reaction is that the Lukpanic cities seem awfully spread out. Sure, they could trade over that whole area; but surely just one part of it is their homeland, and most of their cities should be clustered there. (It seems to me that the most likely place for such a cluster is the peninsula where you've placed Kpitamoa, including the island Poalugbum is on. I'd suggest putting more of the cities there.)
I have more to say about the whole Western scenario, but I think I'll save it for a little later-- it needs its own post, if not its own thread on the Akana forum.
Also: a
map of the sea east of Peilaš, with major cultures as of 400 YP. Athalē, Huyfárah, and Affalinnei are correctly placed, but the others are tentative.
In addition to the correction noted by Cedh, it looks like you too have placed Xšalad too far east. (I'm not clear on exactly where its borders are though...)
Despite my nitpicking though, I have to say all these maps are lovely and I'm happy to see so much new activity in Akana!
By the by...
zompist wrote:That's quite a gorgeous map.
And it reminds me that I am very unlikely to get back to the Wippwô (Stinking Mud) people, my derivative of Radius's Naidda. So I'd be happy if someone else took it over.
While we have your attention, is there any chance you could spend a few minutes looking over
this? The main question is how Fáralo would borrow the island name /wAnEnu~tEjE~/, but if you approve or disapprove of anything else in that post it'd be nice to know.
(
A few months ago, you wrote:Oops, someone did point out the Fáralo questions to me, and I've been forgetting about them. I'll try to respond in a few days.
)
Thanks!